Combined endovascular and surgical management of a case of Cobb syndrome
- 1 Radiodiagnosis, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Patna, Bihar, India
- 2 Radiodiagnosis, Sanjay Gandhi Post Graduate Institute of Medical Sciences, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh, India
- 3 Neurosurgery, Sanjay Gandhi Post Graduate Institute of Medical Sciences, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh, India
- Correspondence to Dr Vivek Singh; singhvivek79@rediffmail.com
Abstract
Cobb syndrome is a rare neurocutaneous disorder characterised by spinal and cutaneous vascular malformations in a metameric distribution. Managing such cases is a challenge for the interventionists and neurosurgeons as the results are often suboptimal. We describe a case of Cobb syndrome in a young male child who presented clinically with acute paraparesis and lower backache. On radiological workup, an intradural perimedullary complex spinal arteriovenous fistula was seen with presence of subarachnoid haemorrhage in the spinal canal and compressive myelopathy. There was a haemangioma in paraspinal muscles and a maculopapular cutaneous lesion in the lower back. He was treated with combined endovascular embolisation and surgical intervention and showed significant clinical improvement on follow-up.
Background
Cobb syndrome is a rare segmental neurocutaneous disease with poorly understood pathophysiology and unknown natural history. The exact incidence is not known with less than 50 cases reported in literature.1 2 These patients have spinal and soft-tissue/cutaneous vascular malformations in a metameric segmental distribution. Cutaneous involvement is characterised by presence of haemangiomas, vascular malformations and naevi. Mostly, it presents clinically in late childhood with cutaneous stigmata, sensory/motor neurological deficits and pain. The spinal vascular malformations usually have complex angioarchitecture and complete obliteration of the spinal lesion is not possible in most of the cases. So, these cases are treated with intent to halt the progress of neurological deficits rather than to cure it.
Case presentation
A 5-year-old male child presented with sudden onset gradually progressive weakness in bilateral lower limbs and pain in lower back for 2 weeks. The patient had to put excessive strain during micturition and defecation for last 1 week. There was no history of trauma, fever, seizure or spinal surgery. On clinical evaluation, the patient was conscious, oriented and his higher mental functions were intact. There was symmetric paraparesis (bilateral lower limb power—3/5 at hip, 4/5 at knee and 1/5 at ankle), decreased sensation below the level of groin bilaterally and loss of bladder and bowel control. A large maculopapular cutaneous lesion was noted in lower back and gluteal region. The cutaneous lesion was present since birth and progressively increasing in size with the growth of body size of the patient (figure 1A).
(A) Clinical image showing maculopapular lesion over lower back, (B) Sagittal MRI spine T2-weighted image (T2WI) showing multiple serpiginous flow voids in spinal canal and a large pouch like flow void causing compressive myelopathy. A fluid-fluid level (arrow) within sacral spinal canal suggestive of subarachnoid haemorrhage. (C) Axial T2WI MRI at D12 level showing the spinal canal occupied by the large venous pouch with compressed spinal cord anteriorly and (D) at D11 level showing spinal cord oedema, (E) coronal T2 fat saturated image showing hyperintense haemangioma in right paraspinal muscle with multiple flow voids within, (F) precontrast axial T1WI and (G) postcontrast T1WI axial and (H) coronal sections showing avid enhancement of the soft-tissue haemangioma.
Investigations
The patient underwent MRI of spine which showed multiple T2 hypointense serpiginous flow voids in the spinal canal with a large sac like structure at D12 vertebral level compressing over posterior surface of the lower spinal cord. There was associated lower spinal cord oedema. A fluid-fluid level was seen in sacral spinal canal suggestive of subarachnoid haemorrhage (figure 1B–D). A T2 hyperintense and T1 hypointense avidly enhancing lesion was seen in paraspinal muscle on right side suggestive of haemangioma (figure 1E–H). Subsequently, the patient underwent diagnostic digital subtraction angiography (DSA) which showed spinal perimedullary arteriovenous fistula (AVF) supplied by posterior spinal arteries (PSA) arising from radiculo-pial branches of posterior intercostal arteries at right L3, right D11 and left D10 vertebral levels. The fistula was also fed by small branches of anterior spinal artery (ASA) arising from radicle-medullary branch of posterior intercostal artery at left D9 vertebral level. The drainage was in dilated perimedullary veins (figure 2A–E). A large venous sac was seen at D12 vertebral level at the site of fistula. Abnormal vascular blush was noted in the region of right paraspinal muscle and gluteal region which was supplied predominantly by branches of right posterior intercostal artery at L3 vertebral level (figure 2D–E). Small feeders to the haemangioma were also coming from right posterior intercostal artery at L2 vertebral level and right internal iliac artery. The DSA findings were consistent with type IVc perimedullary spinal AVF (anatomical location-based classification) with haemangioma in right paraspinal muscle and gluteal region. Based on the clinical features, MRI and DSA findings, a diagnosis of Cobb syndrome with subarachnoid haemorrhage in spinal canal and compressive myelopathy from dilated venous sac at fistula site was made.
Spinal DSA images: (A) right D11 posterior intercostal artery DSA shows perimedullary arteriovenous fistula (AVF) supplied by posterior spinal artery (PSA), large venous sac (arrow) at the fistula site with dilated perimedullary veins. The AVF is also supplied by (B) PSA at left D10, (C) ASA at left D9 and (D, E) PSA at right L3 vertebral levels. Right paraspinal muscle haemangioma (arrow in D, E) fed by right L3 posterior intercostal artery. (F) Microcatheter in right D11 PSA and (G) right L3 PSA reaching up to the fistula site with n-BCA:lipiodol injection. Postembolisation posterior intercostal artery DSA at (H) right D11, (I) right L3 and (J) left D9 vertebral levels shows near complete embolisation of AVF and patent PSAs and ASA. ASA, anterior spinal artery; DSA, Digital Subtraction Angiography.
Treatment
The patient was taken for endovascular embolisation of the spinal AVF and paraspinal muscle haemangioma. Under general anaesthesia, through right transfemoral route, right D11 and L3 posterior intercostal arteries were sequentially accessed. The PSAs, supplying the AVF were super selectively cannulated and 1.2F microcatheters were advanced up to the fistula site. Then the AVF was embolised using n-butyl cyanoacrylate:lipiodol (1:2.5 dilution) solution ensuring that the liquid embolising agent reaches into the venous sac as well as the immediate draining vein of the AVF (figure 2F–G). Postprocedure DSA showed near complete embolisation of the AVF and patent ASA and PSAs (figure 2H–J). Then the arterial feeders from right L3 and L2 posterior intercostal arteries and right internal iliac artery which were supplying the haemangioma were selectively cannulated and embolised using 300–500 μm poly vinyl alcohol particles. A sketch diagram depicting the angioarchitecture of the spinal AVF in this case is provided (figure 3).
Labelled sketch diagram showing the type IVc spinal AVF supplied by anterior spinal artery (ASA) and posterior spinal artery (PSA) branches and draining into perimedullary veins. (Illustration by: VS). AVF, arteriovenous fistula.
The patient was taken for surgery the next day. The surgical procedure involved laminectomy of D11–L1 levels. The epidural space was normal in appearance. The dura was opened in the midline. The embolised AVF was located subpially. Due to embolisation, the AVF mass was avascular, firm and easy to handle during surgery. This embolised AVF mass was elevated from the dorsal aspect of the cord, starting cranially and then proceeding caudally. The gliotic plane between the lesion and the underlying spinal cord was exploited to remove the fistula. In the central part of the lesion, an embolised large venous sac was seen piercing the spinal cord which was communicating with the ventral subdural space. This was divided in line with the rest of the lesion, leaving behind an embolised stump of the venous sac. Embolised venous channels were also removed to free the exiting nerve roots from the conus medullaris. During the entire procedure, somatosensory evoked potential and motor evoked potentials were monitored for physiological monitoring and function preservation. Intra-operative indocyanine green dye showed no filling of abnormal vessels (figure 4A–F).
(A) Subpially located embolised perimedullary spinal AVF. Normal spinal cord can be seen above and below the lesion, covered by a shiny pial membrane. (B) On intraoperative indocyanine green (ICG) angiogram, the embolised segment appeared black (yellow arrow) due to lack of flow while some flow into the fistula was still noted coming from caudal aspect (red pointer). (C) Thrombosed blue venous outflow (yellow arrow), located on the left lateral aspect of the cord. (D) The subpial mass of partially embolised peri medullary AVF was gradually dissected off the cord, starting cranially and going towards the caudal aspect. (E) Large thrombosed venous pouch piercing the spinal cord (marked with a yellow StAR) which was partially decompressed. (F) After completion of the procedure, the caudal feeding artery, embolised fistula mass were confirmed to have been taken care off on ICG angiography. Normal spinal cord perfusion was seen (marked with red arrow). AVF, arteriovenous fistula.
Outcome and follow-up
Postsurgery, the patient showed gradual improvement in bilateral lower limb power and sphincteric functions. The lower limbs power improved to 3/5 at hip, 4/5 at knee and 3/5 at ankle.
At discharge, the postoperative wound was healthy and the patient was able to void voluntarily. The patient has both subjective and objective improvement at 4 months follow-up. The sphincteric functions have further improved while the power in the lower limbs have improved to 4/5 at hips, 4+/5 in the knees while it has remained the same in bilateral ankle joints.
Discussion
Cobb syndrome is a rare clinical entity characterised by presence of spinal arteriovenous vascular malformation/fistula (AVM/AVF) and haemangioma/cutaneous naevus in the same metameric segment. It was first described by Cobb.3–5 Usually, it manifests clinically in late childhood with onset of neurological symptoms although adults are not infrequently affected.6–9 Common presenting symptoms pertain to spinal subarachnoid haemorrhage (SAH)/haematomyelia and neurological deficits. Other clinical features include progressive sensory deficits, bladder-bowel incontinence and pain.7 10 The acute SAH results from rupture of the aneurysm/dilated venous sac or thrombosis of the draining vein adjacent to the AVM. In cases presenting with progressive neurological deficits, the dilated venous sac compresses over the spinal cord surface. In our case also the MRI showed evidence of spinal canal SAH and presence of large venous sac at fistula site causing compressive myelopathy.
Cobb syndrome is a non-hereditary genetic disease.7 10 During embryogenesis, the spinal cord, vertebrae and soft-tissue structures derive their vascular supply from dorsal segmental arteries in respective metameric distribution. Any defect in angiogenesis and migration of vascular cells during embryogenesis leads to defective differentiation of vascular tissues at their final location in same metameric segment.7 10 This explains the metameric distribution and involvement of more than one type of tissues in this disease. It is also suggested that the earlier the occurrence of the defect in angiogenesis, the larger will be the area affected in that metameric segment.5 7 In our case, the most dominant supply to the spinal AVF was arising from radiculo-pial branch of right posterior intercostal artery at L3 vertebral level. The soft-tissue haemangioma and cutaneous lesion were also supplied by branches of the same posterior intercostal artery. This finding supports the metameric involvement at right L3 vertebral level in our case. Familial predisposition is known and hence some advocate MRI screening of the neural axis to rule out any coexisting cranial or spinal vascular malformation.3 11 12
Due to rarity and inconsistent natural history, there is no established optimal treatment guidelines available in literature.3 7 13 The treatment has to be tailored and individualised based on several factors like type of spinal vascular malformation, location of the nidus/fistula site, number and type of arterial supply, presence of aneurysm/venous sac and level of the lesion in spinal canal. Since the spinal vascular malformations often have very complex anatomy and angioarchitecture, it is not always possible to completely obliterate/excise the lesion. Attempts to curative embolisation/surgical interventions in these cases pose significant risk of neurological deficits. So, the goal of therapy in most of the cases is halting the progress of the disease rather than to cure it and endovascular partial embolisation is preferred first-line approach.3 5 7 10
Type IV spinal AVFs have been managed using surgery alone, embolisation alone or a combination.14 So far, the best results are obtained with a combination of preoperative embolisation, followed by surgery. The role of surgery in this setting is possible interruption of remaining arterial feeders and decompression of the spinal cord. The latter is achieved with either resection of the embolised fistula mass, or coagulation-shrinkage with or without duraplasty. Preoperative embolisation helps by reducing the vascularity of the lesion for better surgical handling and making the lesion identifiable by dint of the cast effect of the embolising agent.14 15 Proximal ligation of the arterial supply to a spinal AVF is not curative, rather it only provides a temporary benefit. Eventually there is formation of multiple small collaterals leading to treatment failure. The key surgical objectives include: interruption of the arteriovenous shunt, preservation of the main draining vein of the spinal cord and decompression of the spinal cord. In our patient, the endovascular team took care of all feeders, except the one coming out of the ASA, considering the risks involved. The surgical team aimed to take down this feeder and decompress the cord. While the ventral feeder could not be reached, we could remove the sub pial mass along with all abnormal vasculatures.
Thus, though the goal of therapy in Cobb syndrome is to prevent progression of the disease, curative treatment is still possible in a few cases like in our case where preplanning, proper evaluation of the angioarchitecture and use of combined modalities including endovascular and surgical interventions led to complete removal of the spinal vascular malformation without complications.7 Factors which led to a favourable outcome in our case were extramedullary location of the spinal vascular malformation, lower spinal canal level of the lesion and achievement of near complete endovascular embolisation of the fistula without compromising perfusion of the spinal cord. This was followed by timely surgical intervention to remove the embolised fistula along with thrombosed abnormal vasculature. The latter led to resolution of the mass effect and compressive myelopathy.
Learning points
-
Cobb syndrome is a rare neurocutaneous disease characterised by spinal vascular malformation and haemangioma with cutaneous stigmata involving same metameric segment.
-
Prior knowledge of this disease, high index of clinical suspicion and radiological work-up including MRI of the spine is required to diagnose this condition early in patients presenting with symptoms of spinal subarachnoid haemorrhage or compressive myelopathy.
-
Treatment is mainly aimed at halting the progress of the disease and include endovascular embolisation and surgical excision with suboptimal long-term prognosis in most of the cases.
-
In selected cases with extramedullary location of the spinal vascular malformation, complete cure can be achieved with combined endovascular and surgical interventions.
Ethics statements
Patient consent for publication
Footnotes
-
Twitter @BapiBarman_IR
-
Contributors VS and SNP conceived the manuscript. SNP prepared the manuscript. BB and KKD collected the images and also helped in manuscript preparation. SNP and VS edited the manuscript. The final manuscript was read and approved by all the authors.
-
Funding The authors have not declared a specific grant for this research from any funding agency in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors.
-
Case reports provide a valuable learning resource for the scientific community and can indicate areas of interest for future research. They should not be used in isolation to guide treatment choices or public health policy.
-
Competing interests None declared.
-
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
- © BMJ Publishing Group Limited 2022. No commercial re-use. See rights and permissions. Published by BMJ.
References
Use of this content is subject to our disclaimer